I Read a Forgotten Realms Series and It Was Actually Good!

Let me premise this by saying two things that are important for this. The first is, the reason I (re)-read this series is because I’m doing a bit of research on some possible “from the sea” type threats for my current campaign, and I seemed to remember this series being filled with threats that could be useful (inspiration, not theft, I PROMISE!). The second thing is, I’m really not a big Forgotten Realms fan. I used to read the novels occasionally, but it was really always more of a curiosity thing than anything else, since everyone’s always talking about Drizzt and Elminster. Both in terms of novels and the setting itself, I feel as though the entire world of Faerun revolves way too much around the really awesomely powerful good guy inevitably winning over the bumbling baffoon-like antics of the “bad guys.” Of course, many novels and movies use this ethos (many of which I like), but my problem with the Forgotten Realms is that there seems to be some sort of God-Shattering NPC in every city in the Realms. How can there ever be a threat to the world, or even to just a small little hamlet, when there is always a level 30+ wizard hanging around to right the wrongs? The novels are full of these situations, and the setting itself is full of NPCs who overshadow the players by being too powerful to be beaten. Of course, supposedly 4th edition FR has fixed some of these problems – we’ll see.

With that being said, every now and then, I did read a good ‘Realms book or series. One such is a trilogy from 1999 – 2000 called “The Threat From the Sea,” by Mel Odom, which I just finished (re)-reading. The series tells the tale of the world beneath the oceans rising up to attack the surface world. It follows the adventures of Jherek Wolf’s-Get, Pacys the bard, and Laqueel the malenti as they try to find their place in the world during this time of crisis. The series takes place between the Forgotten Realms years of 1354, the Year of the Bow and 1369, the Year of the Gauntlet, which, at this point, is over a hundred years prior to the “current timeline.”

Much like the ‘Realms deity Lathander, who becomes a powerful force in the series, the trilogy is very much about birth and renewal, about letting go of old regrets, and about cherishing new loves and friendships. The Threat From the Sea follows the points of view of three characters who all have roles to play in the upcoming events, but none of whom know what those roles may be.

The main protagonist of the story is Jherek, a young sailor who is running from a haunted past. He was born of one of the bloodiest pirates ever to sail the Sea of Swords, and is branded with his evil father’s emblem on his shoulder, which is all but a death sentence in all the cities of the Sword Coast. Jherek feels he has always been cursed with ill fortune, and indeed, reading through the series and his trials, I tend to agree. By the end, it is obvious that he has been tested, strained, and poured through a sieve by a loving being who only wants the best for him (I may discuss the God/Job relationship some other time, and what I think of a “benevolent” deity “testing” people in this way), but it sure takes a long time to realize this. Jherek is a very emotional character, wanting desperately to believe in love, but not willing to believe that it could happen to him. He keeps Sabyna, the mage he obviously loves, at an arms distance (or even further if he can help it), and is unwilling to reveal the secrets of his past to anyone, save the paladin Glawinn.

The villain of the series is Iakhovas, a powerful sorcerer who is uncovered by Laqueel as she searches for “One Who Swam with Sekolah,” and will supposedly be the savior of her people, the sahaguin. He is a deliciously evil and ruthless villain who obviously has his own goals and agenda throughout the series, even though he constantly uses his former relationship with Sekolah as a podium from which to wage his wars on the world. His true nature and true goals are not revealed until very close to the end of the series, in an explosive final battle that unfortunately was much like an explosion – a lot of bang, but quick, which left me looking through the smoke to see what happens next. In fact, if I have one complaint with the series as a whole, it is that it was about fifty pages too short. Had Odom made the final battle a little longer, and had just a bit more happen, with a bit more of an epilogue, I could easily give this series props as a great fantasy series. I left the series with a feeling of wanting to know everything else about these characters, which is always good, but I also left with a feeling that a bit more should have happened to resolve the series properly, which is not really a good thing. I’ll give the series a solid “good” rating, and hope that Odom decides to write a sequel someday.

So did (re)-reading this series help me out with my research for the hopefully-soon oceanic adventures I’m planning? Honestly, not so much. There were some great at-sea moments that were somewhat inspirational for my cause, but I’m probably going to have to look more into the Cthulhu mythos (Shadow at Innsmouth?) to get what I’m really looking for in this. However, I will say that out of reading this, I’ve rediscovered something that Forgotten Realms authors should really check out. This is a story written very well about a real hero. Not the kind that was always born to be a hero, always had the power to be a hero, and simply had to step into his shoes to fulfill his role, but rather about a hero who was forced into situations he didn’t understand (and didn’t deserve!), and made the best of his situations, rising to an occasion to win the day (and win the fair lass, while he’s at it). It reminded me a bit of my favorite fantasy series EVAR, Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn, by Tad Williams, in that the hero really was just an ordinary guy, doing ordinary things, and had to prove his worth by the end. Maybe new 4E Forgotten Realms can take a look back at this series and see some tips and pointers on how to make the FR more about the real heroes again.

As an ending note, I would like to mention my favorite character in the stories, Glawinn, a paladin of Lathander, who becomes a father-figure to Jherek. Glawinn is easily one of the most well-written paladins (or paladin-type characters, since many novels have code-driven knights, just not called paladins) to date in a fantasy series (that I’ve read). He has a passion for life and love that is obvious in every single one of his actions, from his courteous speech to his chivalrous actions in battle. He is a deadly warrior, but one whom believes in the good of everyone. He even prays for the soul of a dying pirate he had just slain in one-on-one combat, because he honestly believed it would help the pirate find his way into the afterlife. If all paladins were like this, they’d be a bit more interesting to read about.

So yeah, this turned into a bit more of a review, and a bit less of a tale of how I planned my undersea adventures, but I’m glad I (re)-read the series anyway. If you like novels about heroes who have to struggle to accomplish their goals, and you don’t mind filtering through the ridiculous-to-pronounce names that fall from the pages of all Forgotten Realms books, I suggest reading this series.


8 thoughts on “I Read a Forgotten Realms Series and It Was Actually Good!

  1. Well, I will regret saying this, but I’m sold. I believe that if the book made such a nice impression on you it must be worth to give it a look.

    Regrettably, those books are not usually available where I live so I’ll try to see if there’s any option for PDF purchase? (I doubt it.)

    To throw the ball back at you then… you said that this was a ‘good’, let’s say solid, fantasy series. Would there be any one that you would particularly recommend (among this D&D like books?)

    I’ll wait to see what’s your input on that.

  2. @Haaldaar – I’ll certainly give it a try. Honestly, I tend to be rather pessimistic about D&D-esque books, but I’ve heard decent things about Richard Baker’s writing in general, so sounds like a good one to try out.

    @blunderbuss – Are you asking if I have specific authors I would recommend outside of D&D, or just in D&D books? If it’s the first, then yes, and the list can get long, but to name a few:
    Steven Brust – Vlad Taltos Series
    Tad Williams – Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn
    Robert Jordan – Wheel of Time
    Ursula K Leguin – Earthsea Saga
    Stephen King – Dark Tower Series

    There are many others, but those are the big names (IMO). If your question was the second version, then no, unfortunately I don’t have any other authors to recommend in the various D&D book series.

    Thanks for reading!

  3. There was a great Dragon magazine article that had the ecology of the deep ones in it. I cannot remember the issue, but any one of the online indexes could probably help with that.

    Otherwise, the morkoth and Locathah are excellent bad guys, as well as the legendary Kraken (which also got the Dragon ecology treatment.)

    The Savage tide series from Dungeon magazine also had a number of ocean related encounters.

    As far as literature goes…tough one. I tend to read more sci-fi than I do fantasy these days. The Dark Tower is a DEFINITE winner in my book. Read that damned series for almost 15 years, and WOW what an ending! What were we talking about again?

  4. @Donny – Man, I would love to know which Dragon magazine that is. Would I be correct in assuming that it was one of the Ocean-themed issues, or did it show up randomly in some other issues?

    Never read Dungeon, so know nothing about Savage Tide, unfortunately.

    Thanks for reading!

  5. Thank you very much for the list of authors/books, I am currently “kind of” reading the Dark Tower series (I came to a halt when it got into extended flashback mode after Blaine), and I have heard about some of the other authors.

    As an aside, I also tend to stray towards sci-fi rather than fantasy these days but I like both genres. I have personally never read anything better than the Amber Chronicles by Roger Zelazny (measured by the OMGs per page ratio.)

    That being said the Tad Williams books sound interesting, are we talking about 3 books there?


  6. Yeah, it’s a series called Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn. The three books in the series are “The Dragonbone Chair,” “Stone of Farewell,” and “To Green Angel Tower.” I highly recommend them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s